Neither gin is better. They are built for different things. Tanqueray is a classic London dry: bold, juniper-led and crisp, great in a martini or a Negroni. Hendrick’s is softer and more floral, with cucumber and rose, and shines in a gin and tonic. The right one depends on what you like and what you are mixing.
Tanqueray in a nutshell
Tanqueray is one of the best-known London dry gins in the world. The flagship bottle is famously simple, built on juniper, coriander, angelica and licorice. The result is a dry, piney, assertive gin that holds its own in a cocktail. It is bottled at a higher strength than Hendrick’s, which is part of why it cuts through mixers so well.
There is also Tanqueray No. Ten, a citrus-forward version made with fresh fruit. It is brighter and rounder than the original. At The Winslow we pour Tanqueray No. Ten for $15, and our menu describes it as lemon and lime.
Choose Tanqueray if: you like a classic, juniper-heavy gin, you drink martinis or Negronis, or you want a gin that tastes unmistakably like gin.
Hendrick’s in a nutshell
Hendrick’s is made in Scotland and is known for adding cucumber and rose to the gin after distillation. It is lighter on juniper and softer on the palate, which makes it a favorite with people who think they don’t like gin. It is usually served with a slice of cucumber instead of lime.
Hendrick’s matters to us. Our co-founder started out drinking supermarket gin, and it was a bottle of Hendrick’s, years later, that showed him what gin could be. We pour it for $14, and our menu lists its notes as cucumber and rose.
Choose Hendrick’s if: you prefer floral, gentle flavors, you are new to gin, or you want a refreshing gin and tonic on a warm day.
Tanqueray vs. Hendrick’s, side by side
- Style: Tanqueray is a London dry. Hendrick’s is a modern, floral gin.
- Juniper: strong in Tanqueray, lighter in Hendrick’s.
- Signature notes: Tanqueray is piney and dry, with citrus in No. Ten. Hendrick’s is cucumber and rose.
- Best garnish: lime or grapefruit for Tanqueray, cucumber for Hendrick’s.
- Best drink: Tanqueray for a martini or Negroni, Hendrick’s for a gin and tonic.
What about Bombay Sapphire?
Bombay Sapphire is another big name people compare with Tanqueray. It is also a London dry, but lighter and more aromatic, with a peppery edge. If Tanqueray is bold and Hendrick’s is floral, Bombay Sapphire sits somewhere in between. Bombay Sapphire isn’t on our current list, but if you like its style, ask the bartender for something similar.
The best way to decide: taste them together
Reading tasting notes only gets you so far. The quickest way to settle it is to put the gins side by side. At The Winslow you can try them side by side in a gin flight: four gins of your choice for $30, each a one-ounce pour with its own tonic and botanicals.
A good flight for this question: Tanqueray No. Ten, Hendrick’s, a classic London dry like Ford’s, and something left-field like Roku or Gin Mare. You will know which way you lean by the second glass.
Other gins to try if you like each one
If you love Tanqueray, try Ford’s or Hayman’s London Dry. If you love Hendrick’s, try Uncle Val’s (lemon, cucumber, pepper) or Whitley Neill Aloe Cucumber. We once hosted a Whitley Neill gin club, and it is a good example of how far the cucumber style can go.
Want something gentle? Read our guide to the smoothest gin to drink.
Frequently asked questions
Is Hendrick’s a London dry gin?
No. Hendrick’s is made in Scotland and adds cucumber and rose after distillation, so it isn’t classed as a London dry.
Which is better for a martini, Tanqueray or Hendrick’s?
Most bartenders reach for Tanqueray for a classic dry martini because of its juniper backbone. Hendrick’s makes a softer, more floral martini, which some people prefer.
Is Tanqueray a bottom shelf gin?
No. Tanqueray is a widely available, respected London dry. It is often a “call” gin at bars, a step up from the well.
Taste the debate for yourself
Come to The Winslow’s gin bar at 243 East 14th Street and settle it at the bar. Over 40 gins, and bartenders happy to argue for their favorite.