The smoothest gins are the ones that go easy on juniper and alcohol burn. Good places to start are Plymouth, Hendrick’s, Roku, The Botanist and slightly sweeter Old Tom gins. They feel soft and rounded rather than sharp and piney, which makes them easy to sip neat, over ice or in a gin and tonic.
What makes a gin “smooth”?
Smoothness is about how a gin feels as much as how it tastes. A few things play a part:
- Juniper level. Juniper gives gin its piney bite. Gins that dial it back feel gentler.
- Strength. Higher-proof gins, like navy strength, feel hotter. Standard-strength gins feel softer.
- Botanicals. Citrus, chamomile, cucumber and floral notes round out the flavor.
- Sweetness. Old Tom gins have a touch of sweetness, which takes the edge off.
- How it is served. A big glass, plenty of ice and a good tonic make any gin smoother.
Smooth gins worth trying
All of these are on The Winslow’s list, with the flavor notes from our menu.
- Plymouth ($14): lemon, ginger, clove. Earthier and softer than most London drys, and a bartender’s favorite.
- Hendrick’s ($14): cucumber and rose. Light on juniper and very approachable.
- Roku ($13): lemon, chamomile, clove. A Japanese gin that is delicate and balanced.
- The Botanist ($14): orange, chamomile, cinnamon. Rounded and gently herbal.
- Barr Hill ($14): lemon, juniper, bee pollen. Made with raw honey for a soft, rich texture.
- Himbrimi Old Tom ($16) and Barr Hill Tom Cat ($16): slightly sweeter Old Tom styles that are lovely sipped slowly.
- Monkey 47 ($19): orange, cinnamon, rosebud, juniper. Complex, but beautifully balanced.
Gins that are less smooth (but still great)
If you like a bit of bite, try a classic London dry like Ford’s or Hayman’s, or a navy strength gin like Conniption. They are bolder and more juniper-heavy, which makes them perfect for martinis and Negronis. Our comparison of Tanqueray vs. Hendrick’s shows how big the difference between a bold and a soft gin can be.
How to make gin taste smoother
- Serve it cold. Chill the glass and use lots of ice.
- Choose the right tonic. A drier, premium tonic lets the gin shine without extra sugar.
- Garnish to match. Cucumber with Hendrick’s, citrus with Roku, an olive with Gin Mare.
- Add herbs. Rosemary, thyme or basil can soften sharp edges. Read more about gin and herbs.
Taste a few before you choose
The best way to find your smoothest gin is to try several side by side. At The Winslow, our gin and tonic flight lets you pick four gins for $30, each with its own tonic and botanicals. A smooth flight might be Plymouth, Hendrick’s, Roku and The Botanist.
If you get hooked, join us at gin club, a ticketed tasting on select Tuesdays that focuses on one gin each night. You learn how it is made and mix two cocktails with it yourself.
New to gin?
Plenty of people tell us they don’t like gin, usually because of one harsh drink years ago. A smooth gin in a well-made gin and tonic often changes their mind. Tell the bartender what you usually drink, whether that is vodka soda, white wine or beer, and they will steer you. Our post on what your gin says about you is a fun place to start, and our guide to ordering a gin and tonic helps at the bar.
Frequently asked questions
What is the smoothest gin for beginners?
Hendrick’s and Roku are two of the easiest starting points: gentle on juniper, with cucumber, rose, citrus and chamomile notes.
Is Plymouth gin smoother than London dry?
Many people find it so. Plymouth is softer and earthier, with less of the sharp juniper edge of a classic London dry.
Can you drink gin neat?
Yes. Smooth gins such as Old Tom styles, Monkey 47 or The Botanist are pleasant sipped neat or over a single large ice cube.
Find your smooth gin at The Winslow
We pour over 40 gins at 243 East 14th Street, between the East Village and Union Square. See the list on our NYC gin bar page, then come in and let the bartender find your favorite.