The best gin bar in New York City is the one that treats gin as the main event: a long list of named gins, tonics matched to each bottle, flights so you can compare, and bartenders who can steer you to something new. At The Winslow on East 14th Street, that means over 40 gins and a proper gin and tonic every night.
“Best” is personal, of course. A cocktail bar with three gins on the shelf can make a lovely martini. But if you search for a gin bar, you probably want more than that. You want choice, a bit of guidance and a drink that shows off what the gin actually tastes like.
What makes a real gin bar
Plenty of NYC bars pour gin. Far fewer are built around it. Here is what separates the two.
- A list you can read. A good gin bar names every gin on the menu and tells you what it tastes like. You should not have to guess what the “house gin” is.
- Range. London dry, Plymouth, Old Tom, navy strength, sloe, and modern craft gins from around the world. Different styles for different moods.
- Tonic that fits the gin. A floral gin and a juniper-heavy gin should not get the same tonic and a lime wedge.
- A way to compare. Flights let you taste three or four gins side by side, which is the quickest way to learn what you like.
- People who care. The bartender should be able to ask what you normally drink and hand you something you will enjoy.
How The Winslow does it
We are a British pub at 243 East 14th Street, between the East Village and Union Square, and gin is the reason we are more than another pub. If you want a proper gin bar in NYC, this is what you will find.
Our menu lists more than 40 gins by name, each with its flavor notes. Hendrick’s comes with cucumber and rose. Gin Mare comes with a rosemary-stuffed olive. Empress leans grapefruit and coconut. Monkey 47 brings orange, cinnamon, rosebud and juniper. Most single pours are $13 to $16, and any gin can go with a premium tonic for $4 more.
We serve gin and tonics the Spanish way, in a big glass, finished with spices, dried fruit and botanicals from the jars along the bar. It is the easiest way to taste what a gin really does.
Try a flight before you pick a favorite
If you can’t decide, don’t. Our gin and tonic flight is $30 for four gins of your choice, each a one-ounce pour with its own tonic and botanicals. Line up a classic London dry against a newer craft gin and the differences jump out. Most people find a new favorite by the third glass.
Not sure which gins to put on the paddle? Our guide to the smoothest gins to drink is a good place to start if you’re new to gin.
Gin cocktails, too
A gin bar should do more than gin and tonics. Our house gin cocktails are $16 and change with the season. Right now that includes Another Martini (Hendrick’s, Lillet Blanc, Italicus and a dill aquavit) and Powder to the People (Gunpowder gin, St. Germain, Pama and lemon). For the classics, see our list of five classic gin cocktails, or read about the Aviation.
For the real gin lovers: gin club
On select Tuesdays we host a ticketed gin club tasting. Each night puts one gin in the spotlight. You hear how it is made, you mix two cocktails with it yourself and bites come round from the kitchen. The gin changes every time, so regulars keep coming back.
When to go
The Winslow is open late: until 2 AM Monday to Wednesday, 3 AM on Thursday and Sunday, and 4 AM on Friday and Saturday. The kitchen is open until 11 PM. If you want to try gin for less, come during happy hour (Monday 4 to 7 PM, Tuesday to Friday 4 to 8 PM), when there is an $8 featured gin and tonic with a different gin every day.
We don’t take table reservations. Walk in, grab a stool at the bar and ask for a gin you haven’t tried.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a gin bar in NYC that does gin flights?
Yes. The Winslow on East 14th Street pours a gin and tonic flight of four gins of your choice for $30, any night we’re open. No ticket or booking needed.
How many gins should a good gin bar have?
There is no magic number, but enough to cover the main styles: London dry, Plymouth, Old Tom, navy strength and some modern craft gins. We carry over 40.
Do I need to like gin already?
No. Plenty of our regulars walked in thinking gin tasted like a Christmas tree. Tell the bartender what you normally drink and they will build a gin and tonic to match. Our post on the best ways to enjoy gin has a few more ideas.
Come and find your gin
243 East 14th Street, New York, NY 10003. Take the L to 3rd Avenue, three minutes from Union Square. See the full list on our gin bar page or the menu, then come and taste it.