243 East 14th Street, New York 212-777-7717

How to Order a Gin and Tonic at a Bar (and What Gin Drinks to Ask For)

November 20, 2026

To order a gin and tonic at a bar, name the gin you want (“a Plymouth and tonic, please”), say if you want a premium tonic, and mention any garnish you like. If you don’t know which gin to pick, tell the bartender what flavors you enjoy and let them choose. That is it. No secret handshake.

Step 1: Name your gin

If you just say “gin and tonic,” you get the house gin, often called the well. That is fine, but you are leaving flavor on the table. Naming a brand, called “calling” your gin, costs a little more and makes a big difference. Read more about what gin most bars use and why it matters.

Don’t know any names? Describe what you like:

  • Citrusy: try something like Tanqueray No. Ten or Brooklyn Gin.
  • Floral: Hendrick’s or Mermaid Pink.
  • Herbal or savory: Gin Mare or St. George Terroir.
  • Classic and dry: Ford’s or Hayman’s London Dry.

Step 2: Choose your tonic

Tonic is half the drink. A standard bar tonic is sweet and bubbly. Premium tonics are often drier and less sugary, and some come in flavors that match certain gins. At The Winslow, any gin can be paired with a premium tonic for $4 more.

Step 3: Garnish

Lime is the default in most American bars. A slice of cucumber suits Hendrick’s. Grapefruit works with citrus-forward gins. At a gin bar, the garnish is often chosen to match the gin’s botanicals. We serve ours the Spanish way, in a big glass with spices, dried fruit and botanicals from the jars along our bar.

Step 4: Know the lingo

  • “Tall” or “long”: more tonic, a lighter drink.
  • “Short”: less tonic, a stronger taste of gin.
  • “Double”: two measures of gin.
  • “Light ice”: less dilution, though a full glass of ice actually keeps a G&T colder and fizzier for longer.

What other gin drinks should you order at a bar?

A gin and tonic is only the start. These classics are on most bar menus and are worth knowing.

  • Martini: gin and dry vermouth, stirred, with a twist or an olive.
  • Gimlet: gin and lime. Sailors drank it to keep scurvy away.
  • Negroni: gin, Campari and sweet vermouth. Bitter, bold and grown-up. Read about Negroni Week.
  • Tom Collins: gin, lemon, sugar and soda. Tall and refreshing.
  • French 75: gin, lemon, sugar and Champagne.
  • Aviation: gin, maraschino, crème de violette and lemon. Read our post on the Aviation cocktail.

If you want to try these at home, see our five classic gin cocktails you can make at home.

Ordering at The Winslow

If you want a gin and tonic in NYC done properly, come and see us on East 14th Street. Our menu lists more than 40 gins by name with their flavor notes, so it is easy to point at something that sounds good. Most single pours are $13 to $16.

Our house gin cocktails are $16 and change with the season. Right now that includes Jessica Rabbit (Brockman’s, Lo-Fi Gentian Amaro, lime, grapefruit bitters, rosebud and hibiscus) and Pear-ly Legal (St. George Valley, pear, ginger and lemon).

Can’t decide? Order the gin and tonic flight: four gins of your choice, each with its own tonic and botanicals, for $30. It is the fastest way to learn what you like. Find out more on our gin flight page.

Save money at happy hour

During happy hour (Monday 4 to 7 PM, Tuesday to Friday 4 to 8 PM) we pour an $8 featured gin and tonic made with a different gin every day. Add a premium tonic for $4.

Frequently asked questions

Is it rude to ask the bartender to choose a gin for me?

Not at all. At a gin bar it is the best thing you can do. Tell them what you usually drink and let them pick.

What is the best gin for a gin and tonic?

It depends on your taste. Juniper lovers should try a London dry. If you like something softer, try a floral gin like Hendrick’s. Our guide to Tanqueray vs. Hendrick’s compares two favorites.

How much is a gin and tonic in NYC?

It varies by bar and by gin. At The Winslow, most gins are $13 to $16, plus $4 for premium tonic, and there is an $8 featured gin and tonic during happy hour.

Come and practice

The Winslow, 243 East 14th Street, New York, NY 10003. Walk in, take a stool and order your first called gin. Have a look at our gin bar page first if you want to pick ahead.

Planning a night at The Winslow?

Tell us the date and the headcount. We'll come back with the space that fits and the price, before you commit.