Most bars use an inexpensive London dry gin as their “well” or house gin, the bottle that goes into any drink when you don’t name a brand. It is usually a big, familiar label bought in bulk. If you want something different, you have to ask for it by name, which is called “calling” your gin.
What is well gin?
Behind most bars there is a speed rail, a row of bottles at the bartender’s knees. These are the well spirits: one vodka, one gin, one rum and so on. When you order a “gin and tonic” without naming a gin, the bartender reaches for the well.
Well gin is chosen for price and consistency. It is almost always a London dry style, which is juniper-forward, crisp and built to mix. There is nothing wrong with that. A good London dry makes a perfectly decent gin and tonic. But it is one gin out of hundreds, and it tells you very little about what gin can taste like.
Well, call and top shelf
Bars often think about spirits in three tiers.
- Well: the default pour, the cheapest option.
- Call: a brand you ask for by name. Think of the well-known London dry and Scottish gins most people recognize.
- Top shelf: premium and craft bottles, often small-batch or imported.
Calling a gin usually costs a few dollars more than the well. It is almost always worth it if you care about the taste.
How to order a better gin
Name the gin. Instead of “gin and tonic,” say “Plymouth and tonic” or “Hendrick’s and tonic.” If you don’t know any names, ask the bartender what gins they have and describe what you like: citrusy, floral, herbal or very dry. A good bartender will point you somewhere.
We wrote a whole guide on how to order a gin and tonic at a bar if you want the details.
What a gin bar does differently
At a dedicated gin bar, the choice of gin is the point. At The Winslow, the menu lists over 40 gins by name with their flavor notes, so you pick the bottle rather than getting whatever is in the well. Single pours are mostly $13 to $16, with a premium tonic for $4 more.
A few examples from the list:
- Ford’s: lemon, ginger, coriander. A classic London dry made for bartenders.
- Plymouth: lemon, ginger, clove. Softer and earthier than most London drys.
- Tanqueray No. Ten: lemon and lime. Bright and citrus-led.
- Hendrick’s: cucumber and rose. Floral and gentle.
- Gin Mare: served with a rosemary-stuffed olive. Savory and Mediterranean.
- Conniption Navy Strength: lemon, coriander, rosemary. Bottled strong for those who like it bold.
That range is why people come to a bar with 40+ gins. You can taste how much the base spirit matters, which is impossible when every drink comes from the same bottle.
Taste the difference for yourself
The best way to understand gin is to drink a few side by side. Our gin and tonic flight gives you four gins of your choice for $30, each with its own tonic and botanicals. Put a classic London dry next to a floral or savory gin and you will never think of gin as “just gin” again.
If you are comparing the big names, read our take on Tanqueray vs. Hendrick’s.
Does the gin matter in a cocktail?
Yes, more than people think. In a gin and tonic or a martini there is nowhere for the gin to hide. In a Negroni, the gin has to stand up to Campari and vermouth, so a punchier London dry often works best. If you want to learn more, have a look at our post on Negroni Week or how gin and herbs work together.
Frequently asked questions
Is well gin bad?
Not at all. Most well gins are reliable London drys. They are just chosen for price, not for character.
What is the most common gin style in bars?
London dry. It is juniper-forward, dry and mixes well, which is why it fills most speed rails.
Does The Winslow have a well gin?
Our menu names every gin we pour with its own flavor notes, so you choose the bottle. If you can’t decide, tell the bartender what you like and they will choose for you.
Come and choose your gin
The Winslow, 243 East 14th Street, between the East Village and Union Square. Open late every night. Have a look at our gin bar and come and pick a bottle you’ve never tried.